Untouchable: The Male Gaze, ASU Jazz, and the Phoenix Community

[Note from future Eris: although this essay cost me a lot of friends, I am still proud of it beyond measure. I highly recommend that readers experiencing this essay for the first time consider that these were some of my last words before coming out. (My actual coming-out post went live a little less than two months later, but the two essays were edited concurrently, and the original draft of this essay ended with me coming out.) If I were attempting this essay today—and maybe someday I will—I’d be able to more clearly state that the observations I made regarding my treatment were examples of how the patriarchy clocks and punishes trans people pre-transition. I’d talk more about how some of the women enforced this, too, by sabotaging some of my closest connections and all but ensuring anyone in our community who did date me would be subject to a unique flavor of hell. I kept my mouth shut about that in the original, hoping to keep friendships intact, but that didn’t work out.

I love this essay. I love how committed I was to telling my story as an individual for the first time, rather than trying to flatten my experiences to make them more palatable to large groups of other people. Someday, I owe it another follow-up so I can properly give it its due.]

When I was an undergrad running with the jazz boys, no one wanted to sleep with me.

…Yeah, I didn’t know how to start this one, either. For all my work addressing sexual assault, I actually don’t spend all that much time dealing with sex. (I tend to leave that creative artistry to Rebecca Drapkin, who writes about the consensual side of things.) While I love my body and everything it can do, I’ve grown accustomed to keeping my sexual side to myself. I’m still figuring out how much of it belongs in my artistic life. And though that answer is nonzero, part of why I keep my sex life (and body, and sexuality, and . . .) separate from the rest of my artistic discourse is just because I don’t share all of me with all of you. But part of it isn’t, and there are reasons for that—reasons I can trace back to a very specific time and place—and though I’d rather not discuss any of this, I think it’s time.

“Lead the Change,” Emotional Labor, and Research

Once upon a time, I accidentally opened up a Title IX investigation. “Lead the change,” a professor told me. Hang onto your hats; it gets weirder.

Once upon a time, as an undergrad, I accidentally opened up a Title IX investigation. (Yes, that is absolutely a ridiculous sentence, but it’s true.) I didn’t mean to, but no one had ever told me that “I can’t tell if they’re being sexist assholes or just assholes” was enough to accelerate an issue. So the contents of that conversation went up to Title IX, but the office never followed up. The effort I’d made to highlight the issues at hand completely evaporated, caught between higher admin who evidently decided it wasn’t a priority and faculty who never checked back to hear if anything came of it.

In the aftermath of those moments, though, I remember a comment from a faculty member that’s continually drilled itself into my brain: “You could lead the change.” It was said in earnest, with the feeling like this marked a door opening, a path forward through all the bullshit. And twenty-year-old me probably wanted to believe it was. Lord knows I spend entirely too much time contemplating where, or if, I fit within the greater Phoenix musical community. The thing is, even though I know all the way down to the bottom of my heart the idea was presented with wholly good intentions, it’s become a bit of an unwanted pest.

L to R: Emilee Iuvara, Kezia Madarang, Sofia Klass, Alicia Bobb. The three left-most performers have someone else's hands over their mouths. The performer on the right has her finger raised to her lips in a shushing gesture. Behind them, Eris lies on the ground, in pain. Photo by Eric DeJarnett.

Don’t Shout (And Other Suggestions for Allies-In-Training)

TW: sexual assault. How do you make sure you’re not someone who’s threatening or making assault victims uncomfortable? I try to give you some semblance of an answer.

Earlier this week, I observed to my partner that a lot of my female friends are excited and aggressively supportive of the work I’m doing, both musically and in these posts, but I don’t get nearly the same feedback from my male friends. (Let’s also take a moment to remember: I am a brass player and a composer and occasionally I think about the word “jazz.” Most of my friends are men.) He considered this for a moment, then replied, “I think most of your guyfriends are too scared they’re the people you’re talking about.”

What a freaking moment, right?

That said, it’s a good point. I don’t have a great grasp on where my peers and colleagues think they fall on my spectrum of Nonthreatening Human to Violent Human Who Should Not Be Approached At This Time. And that’s not a question I should be asking them, because it’s not something they’re obligated to tell me. But I wanted to take a moment this week and offer up a series of points that might help the people who worry they’re maybe in the Mildly Threatening Human category (also: this scale does not actually exist) and who might want to become someone women with assaults in their past are comfortable trusting. Working toward being a better person is a great endeavor! I will support you from a distance that feels comfortable for me! If you’re just getting started with that journey, though (or if you’re on that journey or think you’re done with that journey, because we’re never done with that), here’s a few things I think might help: